I am a murderer. I have never lived behind bars, nor have I been prosecuted for my crimes. I have, however, been convicted. Many times throughout my life I have been convicted of hatred and selfishness that caused me to act in ways that killed those around me. I’ve seen my words kill confidence. I’ve seen my judgmental attitude kill hope. I know my critical spirit has left vulnerable hearts broken and bleeding. I grieve over all the times I didn’t even bother to notice how my selfish and hateful actions affected someone close to me.
Today I am compelled to respond to the reactions I’m seeing all around me as people process the news that Osama bin Laden has been killed. We may end up agreeing to disagree about much of what I’m about to say, but I can’t remain silent.
Please understand my heart. Like you, I can describe exactly where I was and what I was doing as I felt the horror of seeing the second plane crash into that tower. I watched, holding my 3-month old daughter close as simultaneous emotions of fear, anger and insecurity engulfed me. I feared the world she would face as she grew into a woman. I cried as I watched the anguish of people walking among the rubble, looking for answers and desperately searching for hope. I hated the evil that caused such destruction. I wanted revenge.
Today, nearly ten years later, I’m trying to explain to my daughter how to process a situation that I still can’t fully understand. As I listened to her questions and prayed for wisdom in how to answer them, God used her to reveal the heart of the matter. My daughter couldn’t get past the fact that Osama bin Laden created the plan, talked people into doing it, and then those people agreed, knowing that they would die in the process. She doesn’t understand how a leader can convince someone to commit obvious suicide while the leader continues to live. She can’t comprehend the magnitude of hopelessness that allows such evil to occur. Neither can I.
Just as she brought her questions to me, I have been bringing my questions to my Abba Father. Why don’t I feel that justice has been served with the death of bin Laden? What is it that I keep feeling like I’m missing about this situation? Why doesn’t the justification of bringing closure to victims make me comfortable with how fellow Christians are reacting to the news? Why do I feel a stone in my stomach every time I read a verse that someone has thrown out there about God’s wrath and God’s justice being accomplished?
As He often does, God allowed me to experience these swirling emotions for a few days before He knew my brain was quiet enough to hear His voice. He allowed me to listen to my child wrestle with things beyond her comprehension before He led me to the deeper understanding I was seeking.
As a follower of Christ, I am called to view the world from a different perspective. I’m called to live against the culture, to be transformed when Jesus renews my mind and allows me to see God’s pleasing, good, and perfect will (Romans 12.2). Sometimes it takes a while before I can move beyond the obvious and into a transformed understanding. Today I finally know why I’ve struggled to see bin Laden’s death from a perspective that isn’t conformed to the pattern around me.
The problem is that we’ve been deceived. Again. Osama bin Laden wasn’t the mastermind behind the destruction and devastation of 9/11. He too was manipulated into seeing what he wanted to see. He was unaware that he was also accepting a suicide mission as he implemented the plan of 9/11. As Christians, we have allowed ourselves to see the face of evil as having a beard and empty eyes. We’ve had the audacity to give evil a name, and we’ve dangerously assumed that we’ve killed the heart of terror. Osama bin Laden was evil, but we should grieve his death rather than celebrate it.
Hang with me here, because I’m not saying that bin Laden wasn’t guilty. I’m not saying that he didn’t deserve to die. I’m saying that evil didn’t start with him, nor will it end with him. I’m saying that as Christians we know the truth; that satan was the mastermind behind 9/11, and that bin Laden was simply a willing and able individual open to the idea. Just as bin Laden sent his followers to their death, the devil manipulates us to carry out his plans for destruction, knowing that we are condemning ourselves in the process. John 8.44 describes the devil as a “murderer from the beginning” and a “liar and the father of lies,” yet we continue to accept comfortable lies as a substitute for hard truths. We celebrate the death of a murderer and justify our joy by seeing ourselves on God’s side and above the temptation of hatred that created 9/11.
As a follower of Jesus, I am called to be the light in the darkness of the world. I am called to see others with the heart of my Father beating in my chest, looking past what they seem and seeing who they are as a child of God. I am called to not only admit but to accept the truth that Jesus died for Osama bin Laden as much as Jesus died for me. I must live with the fact that sin is sin, without hierarchy and without distinction. The wage of sin is death (Romans 6.23), but we as Christians often conveniently forget that the Bible also says that anyone who hates a brother or sister is a murderer (1 John 3.15). It is far more comfortable to sit in judgment than to grieve the fact that one more person died without knowing the hope and salvation that is available through Jesus alone.
Sin is sin. There is no distinction in God’s eyes between those planning murder, those committing murder, or those hating their brother. We’re all guilty. Each of us deserves the same fate as Osama bin Laden. All have sinned and fallen short of the glory of God (Romans 3.23). This is a truth difficult to admit or accept. In a world of compromise, Christians must acknowledge that because God loves us, He doesn’t “grade” sins. There are no “acceptable” sins in the eyes of Holy God. We’re all equal, condemned by different actions but by the same root of sin. Thankfully, we’re also equal in the forgiveness that God so freely gives. Everyone can receive the same measure of hope, regardless of who we are or what we’ve done.
I don’t know where you stand with God, and I don’t know what you think about heaven and hell. I certainly don’t profess to have all the answers. However, I believe with all my heart that events like 9/11 open doors for conversations about evil, hope and justice. I know that it’s difficult to live in a world with such evil and not question why God allows things like this to happen. I understand the frustration that comes when Christians use the Bible as proof of their position but can’t understand or admit that not everyone believes in the authority of the Bible.
Here’s the thing: I don’t know why God allows evil to happen, but I believe with all my heart that He is in control and brings eternal good out of situations intended for permanent destruction. I know that it is impossible to deny the depth of evil that exists in this world, and because of that, I cannot live without the hope that there is a stronger force of good that will ultimately triumph.
Unchallenged and untested faith is not actually faith, but rather a catchy slogan. Until we are willing to face difficult questions and admit that we are not capable of finding the answers or making sense of things on our own, we will never be able to take steps toward faith. Once we accept that Jesus really did die for us and we really do have hope, we must also accept that we are called to share that hope with a hurting world.
We are called to grieve the wages of sin no matter the situation. We are not called to celebrate the destruction of those created in the image of God. We are called to speak the truth in love, and fight against the forces that want everyone to die without hope and with eternal condemnation. We are called to recognize and identify hate no matter how cleverly it disguises itself as justice. I’ve been convicted. Have you?